top of page
Search

How Much Umbrella Insurance Is Enough for Your Business?

Writer: Andy Adams
Andy Adams
1 day ago
4 min read


One question we hear frequently from our customers is: How much umbrella insurance should I buy? What limits should I carry? And what is reasonable for a business like mine?


Unfortunately, there is no “right” answer that question. Every business is different, and the liability exposures businesses face can vary significantly. Cost is also an important consideration. Ultimately, determining the right amount of umbrella coverage requires weighing several factors.


I often think about a story my Dad, Norman, used to tell from a mediation he attended involving one of our customers. During the mediation, the attorney for the opposing side asked what umbrella limits our customer carried. When he heard the answer, he was dismissive. He didn't believe the limits were sufficient and commented that he had never heard of a contractor of that size carrying such low limits.


Norman couldn't help himself. Although he wasn't supposed to speak during the mediation, he blurted out, "Well, I don't think you've ever paid the premium for that umbrella policy, Mr. Lawyer.”  Norman was really proud of himself for that comment!


It was a funny moment, but it illustrates an important point: It's easy to recommend higher insurance limits when you aren't the one paying the premium. The reality is that businesses have to balance their potential liability exposures against the cost of protecting themselves.

So, how do you determine how much umbrella coverage is enough? Here are several factors to consider.


1. Start With Your Contractual Requirements


The first and most basic consideration is what you are contractually obligated to carry.

Many contractors have customer agreements, construction contracts, or other contractual requirements that specify minimum umbrella limits. These requirements may vary depending on the type of work being performed and the customer or project involved.


At a minimum, you want to make sure your umbrella limits satisfy those contractual obligations. Falling short can subject you to breach contract claims that will be a much bigger headache than umbrellas premiums.


2. What Are Other Businesses Like Yours Buying?


Another useful benchmark is what your peers are carrying.


What umbrella limits do businesses of similar size, with similar operations and exposures, typically purchase?


This is an area where your insurance agent can be helpful (amazing, I know). Chances are your agent insures other companies in your industry and has a good understanding of what businesses like yours are purchasing.


Ask your agent what limits other contractors of comparable size are carrying. While your business may have unique exposures, understanding what your peers are doing can provide a useful starting point.


3. Consider Your Potential Catastrophic Loss Scenarios


Another way to approach the question is to consider the types of catastrophic losses your business could realistically face.


An umbrella policy is designed to provide additional liability protection over your underlying general liability, automobile liability, and employers' liability coverage under your workers' compensation program.


These policies address several different exposures:


  • General liability: Bodily injury or property damage to third parties arising from your business operations.

  • Automobile liability: Bodily injury or property damage to third parties resulting from automobile accidents involving your vehicles.

  • Employers' liability: Certain employee injury claims that fall outside the workers' compensation benefit system.


All three exposures can potentially produce catastrophic claims that reach deep into your umbrella coverage.


Of these exposures, automobile liability is where we have seen umbrella limits challenged most frequently.


The frequency and severity of automobile accidents have increased significantly over the last decade. Claims have become increasingly expensive, and large jury verdicts have become a major concern for commercial automobile insurers.


Importantly, you don't have to operate a large fleet to have significant exposure. We've seen judgments in the $10 million to $15 million range essentially exhaust the entire umbrella limits of companies operating fleets smaller than 10 light trucks.


That's an important consideration for smaller contractors. Even a relatively modest fleet can create a substantial liability exposure.


4. Understand What Your Umbrella Actually Covers


The amount of coverage you purchase is important, but so is the quality of that coverage.

You want to make sure your umbrella policy provides coverage consistent with the underlying policies it sits over. In insurance terminology, you're looking for an umbrella that follows form with the underlying coverage.  That means it covers and excludes the same things.


Not all umbrella policies “follow form.” Some contain exclusions or restrictions that aren't found in the underlying general liability, automobile, or employers' liability policies.  As a result, you have to be very careful when choosing an appropriate umbrella policy.  


As a result, you could purchase a substantial amount of umbrella coverage only to discover that certain claims aren't covered because of an exclusion in the umbrella policy.


It's important to have your agent review these provisions and identify any gaps between the underlying policies and the umbrella coverage.  Hint: Price is usually an indicator of the coverage provided.  Which brings us to cost.


5. Consider the Cost and Availability of Coverage


Cost is always a consideration.


Umbrella insurance premiums have increased substantially over the last several years. Much of this increase has been driven by a lack of capacity in the umbrella insurance marketplace.


Insurance is subject to the laws of supply and demand, just like any other product. When fewer insurance carriers are willing to provide large umbrella limits, there is less competition for capacity and premiums rise.


Ten years ago, it was relatively common to find a carrier willing to write the first $10 million of umbrella coverage. Today, that can be extremely difficult. Establishing that initial $10 million layer may require two, three, or even four different insurance carriers.  This can double if not triple the cost of that first layer of insurance.


Ultimately, It's a Business Decision


So, how much umbrella insurance is enough?


There isn't a magic number. The right amount depends on your contractual obligations, the size and nature of your operations, the liability exposures you face, what comparable businesses are purchasing, and the cost of obtaining additional coverage.  Ultimately, it comes down to a business decision: What level of umbrella protection is justified by the cost of the premium?


That's why this is such an important conversation to have with your insurance agent. Your agent should be able to help you evaluate your exposures, understand the available marketplace, identify potential coverage gaps, and determine what limits make sense for your business.


And remember, this isn't a decision you make once and forget. Your business changes, your exposures change, and the insurance marketplace changes. It's a conversation worth revisiting every year at renewal.

 
 
 

Comments


Round-Up-Logo2.png

© 2026 by Adams Insurance Service, Inc.

bottom of page